How does implementing research-based technology coaching methods fosters improved instruction?
By: Darryl Callens
I would first say, the majority of my knowledge came from my reading of the The Impact Cycle. As I began reading chapter 2 of the book, I learned that “one of the major findings from our research is that, for many reasons, coaching likely won’t succeed unless teacher and coach both clearly see what is happening in the classroom” (Knight, 2018, p.27). Implementing research based technology coaching methods foster quality teaching. Without the deep research, we wouldn’t have solid indicators on whether or not coaching is affecting for improving instruction or not.
Personally, as I began to read in chapter one about what does it mean to to improve? My initial thoughts on coaching in my situation was that it could not only benefit the teachers that I would be engaging with but also benefit me. There were several types of coaching that I could use in order to assist in my coaching with others. I found that facilitative coaching and dialogical coaching would be closer to alignment of what type of coaching I would like to foster. “Facilitative coaches see collaborating teachers as equals who make most if not all decisions during coaching” (Knight, 2018, p.10). I learned that this type of coaching is teacher focused and it allows the teacher to feel more empowered in the process.
I was also interested in the dialogical coaching style because it focuses on “inquiry, using questions, listening, and conversational moves to help a teacher become aware of answers he already has inside himself” (Knight, 2018, p.12). This approach benefits the student more and it allows for more organic and real assessments of needs moving forward though the impact cycle. With that said, my initial opinions of coaching is very positive. Chapter one also brought to my attention how much we use coaching in many aspects of our lives.
The bottle line in this type of coaching is being able to improve. “The purpose of coaching is to foster improvement” (Knight, 2018, p.14). There wouldn’t be a need for coaching if we didn’t want to improve. My role as a coach would be to enable my colleagues and their students to improve in a clear and understandable way. That is my opinion on what would be expected from me in this role.
I’ve already identified the teachers who I would be working with in my personal situation and I see it as a way for me to break down the needs that I have in my class. At this point, I understand how to get a clear idea of the reality in classrooms using the teacher and student voices. I can then begin to focus on setting and implementing a goal to hit for the year.
By doing research, we can learn so much. In this case students are the key component to our learning for improved instructions. In chapter two, there came a section where it highlighted learning from students. “Asking students about how learning is proceeding in a class has several advantages. First, students will give teacher and coach powerful information that can help them set goals and monitor progress.
The most effective goals are student focused goals, so it only makes sense that students should be asked for their opinion about learning goals” (Knight, 2018, p.40). If we are talking about education then the core of what we do are geared toward the student. This is why this section was important to me. Student voices should be one of the main components in implementing and supporting quality instruction and improvement.
“Just 46% feel students have a voice in decision making at their school and just 52% believe that teachers are willing to learn fro students (Quaglia Institute for Student Aspirations [QISA], 2013)” (Knight, 2018, p.41). Even in my class and before having to read on this material, I’ve always engaged my students and wanted to know what they felt was important and how could learning be better. So many of my kids felt that they were unheard so those percentages were similar to the type of feedback that I received in my class.
Speaking of feedback, research show the importance of feedback in fostering improved instruction. “Coaching is feedback intended to help us get better at what we do. Finally, evaluation is feedback that tells us how we are doing compared to others or some standard” (Knight, 2018, p.50). The entire goal as mentioned in the impact cycle is to make impact with our teachers as well as students. As coaches, we want to always have improvement on our minds and before we can improve we have to identify what the realities are within our own classrooms.
Once we have a clear vision of where we can improve then we move towards those actions and then develop some types of action goals to reach. The end goal for effective coaching should be asking quality questions. Developing the type of questions that will foster an improved environment for learning for the teacher and student. “Our research on instructional coaching has led us to many insight into many success factors for coaching.
For example, we have learned about the importance of modeling, effective questions, sound communication skills, the most helpful teaching strategies, how to explore data, and so forth. Our most important finding is that goals are essential for coaching success” (Knight, 2018, p.65). Chapter three taught me the importance of what the research says, and I’ll end that with this. “Our research had revealed that goal setting is a vital part of coaching..” (Knight, 2018, p.65).
Reference
Knight, J. (2018). The impact cycle: What instructional coaches should do to foster powerful improvements in teaching. Corwin.


Darryl,
ReplyDeleteI agree that research in the field of instructional coaching has dramatically improved coaching relationships across the field of education. Jim Knight, author of The Impact Cycle, for example, has done an enormous amount of research into the field of coaching. In his book, he mentions the research and practice that goes into the process of developing his unique method for coaching. He describes a process where he is constantly learning new skills and techniques to improve his coaching strategies (Knight, 2017). I agree with your statement that “there wouldn’t be a need for coaching if we didn’t want to improve.” According to Kurz et al., “a growing number of teachers across the United States receive their professional development through instructional coaches (Denton and Hasbrouck 2009, Kraft et al. 2018)” (2022, p. 611). For this reason, it is increasingly important that those of us interested in coaching continue to grow and stay up to date with current research and trends in the field of instructional coaching.
In your post, you talk about student-centered goals and the importance of student voice. I agree that students should be at the center of what we do as teachers and coaches and their experiences should guide our instruction and practice. As I was reading The Impact Cycle, I was really excited about the idea of conducting student interviews. According to Knight, both coaches and teachers “can do a better job of listening to students,” and one way to do that is by “asking students about their experiences inside and outside class” (Knight, 2017, p. 41). One of my absolute favorite things about teaching is building student relationships. I love getting to know my students and I’m excited that this is something that can be carried over into the instructional coaching process as well.
According to Knight’s article in Education Sciences, “professional development that fosters genuine professional learning and leads to real improvements in the classroom has to position teachers as partners, and be job-embedded, explicit, and adaptive” (Knight, 2019, p. 14). It seems that being a life-long learner and willing to always be improving our practice, in addition to working with our colleagues through a partner based coaching process, are two of the most crucial components of Jim Knight’s impact cycle approach to coaching. I am eager to hear how your coaching experiences go; it sounds like you have a great plan in place to begin!
References
Knight, J. (2017). The impact cycle: What instructional coaches should do to foster powerful improvements in teaching. SAGE Publications.
Knight, J. (2019). Instructional Coaching for Implementing Visible Learning: A Model for Translating Research into Practice. Education Sciences, 9. https://ezproxy.montevallo.edu/login?url=https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=EJ1220410&site=ehost-live
Kurz, A., Reddy, L. A., Kettler, R. J., Glover, T. A., Velasquez, M. K., & Kirtman, L. (2022). Workstyle attributes and their relations to instructional coaching behaviours. Professional Development in Education, 48(4), 611–623. https://doi-org.ezproxy.montevallo.edu/10.1080/19415257.2020.1712450
Darryl-
ReplyDeleteI can totally relate to your comment about benefiting as the coach just as much as the coachee. I was on an instructional rounds team for several years and while we were more interested in what the students were doing it was interesting to me to see other teachers. I have always taught CTE so going in to a science classroom or language arts was always eye-opening for me.
While it it not the most recent info on coaching, I read an article by Elena Aguilar where she referenced Gladwell's The Outliers in relation to perfecting ones craft. As discussed in Aguilar(2013) most teachers want to improve and hone their skills. The problem is that not everyone can agree on what professional development is best. I think that is just where coaching can fill a need.
On a side note, after reading the Aguilar article I thought it was interesting that LinkedIn sent me a notification just this morning that I should follow her as we had similar interests. I guess that's algorithms at work!
Aguilar, E. (2013, March 25). How coaching can impact teachers, principals, and students. Edutopia. Retrieved October 6, 2022, from https://www.edutopia.org/blog/coaching-impact-teachers-principals-students-elena-aguilar
Knight, J. (2018). The impact cycle: What instructional coaches should do to foster powerful improvements in teaching. Corwin.